If Lindsay Clancy faces another jury in the deaths of her three children, her lawyer wants jurors to answer two questions in order. Did prosecutors prove she killed them? If so, was she criminally responsible? Her retrial is set for March 29, 2027. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington said he plans to ask the judge to split the trial into those two phases.

What you need to know

  • What divided the jury: Clancy acknowledges strangling Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, at their Duxbury home on Jan. 24, 2023. Prosecutors argued she planned the killings. Her lawyers said postpartum psychosis left her unable to be held criminally responsible. Eleven jurors reportedly favored finding her not guilty by reason of insanity. One favored conviction.
  • The fight over the holdout: In their Nov. 16 petition, Clancy’s lawyers said the jury foreperson warned Judge William Sullivan that one juror was disregarding his instructions on reasonable doubt. Sullivan questioned each juror. The defense argues that further questioning could have given him grounds to excuse the holdout and let deliberations continue. Read the defense petition.
  • Why a retrial is still on the calendar: Sullivan declared a mistrial Sept. 4. In a Nov. 9 ruling, he found that the deadlock made the mistrial necessary and that trying Clancy again would not violate her protection against double jeopardy. Her lawyers are challenging that ruling, reports The Associated Press. The Plymouth County District Attorney signaled prosecutors will again pursue first-degree murder charges.

What’s next

Clancy’s lawyers have asked Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Justice Elizabeth Dewar to hear arguments and refer the case to the full court. Dewar was considering the request Tuesday, Boston.com reported, citing the court docket.

Plymouth Superior Court has scheduled a status hearing for Dec. 30 to discuss trial logistics. Clancy remains in the custody of a state psychiatric hospital.

If you are having suicidal thoughts or believe you are suffering from postpartum psychosis, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.